top of page

How, When, and Where You Practice Piano: What Matters Most?

Oct 27
6 min read

When you have a favorite spot to practice, your playing can reach a new level

How, When, and Where You Practice Piano: What Matters Most?

When you ponder this question, you may be thinking, “They're all important!”

And you would be correct. So why did I bother to ask the question?

How You Practice Can Make a Difference

Over the years, I've noticed that a great deal has been written in books and articles about how to practice. In addition, hundreds of YouTube videos explain and demonstrate effective practice techniques. In fact, I've made many recommendations to my own students during nearly 50 years of teaching.

How you practice can make a huge difference in your piano playing. The more effectively you practice, the better your playing can become.

So why not stop there?

WHEN You Practice Can Make a Difference

One reason is that when you practice, it affects your energy level and concentration.

I once had an adult student who practiced consistently every morning before going to work at an insurance company. With this schedule, he made excellent progress for more than a year.

Then something happened.

A health issue required him to work out with a personal trainer every morning. Consequently, he had to move his piano practice to the evening, often after dinner.

Can you guess what happened?

That's right. He was so tired that he had trouble concentrating and often ended his practice sessions abruptly. He continued to improve his piano playing, but his progress slowed to a snail's pace.


Before you conclude that practicing at night isn't effective, let me tell you about my composition teacher, Tom McKinley (he was also an extraordinary jazz pianist.)

Being a morning person myself, I was shocked when he told me that every night at 11:00 PM, his mind automatically became clear, and he would begin composing for about four hours!

So I'm certainly not suggesting that everyone should practice at the same time of day.

Rather, I believe you should practice when your mind is clear, your energy level is reasonably good, and you have at least some interest in spending time at the piano.


Interestingly, although I'm a morning person, I've often experienced something different while teaching students whose preferred practice time is early evening.

As the lesson progresses, our energy grows, sometimes bringing both of us to a higher level of musical inspiration and enjoyment.

I've also noticed this happening while teaching my six-week composition course.

Sometimes the WHEN becomes the right time simply because the musical experience itself creates energy and enthusiasm—even if it isn't normally your best time of day.

WHERE You Practice Matters, Too

By now, you're probably thinking that I've proven my point: how and when you practice both matter. Well, bear with me a little longer.

I once had a student whose piano was located in an upstairs den. Unfortunately, her parents' bedroom was right next door. As she practiced, they listened constantly and frequently called out comments such as: “You made a mistake!" and "Your timing is off!""Off!" Put more feeling into that song!" and other choice phrases.

If you were practicing in that den, would you want to continue playing the piano?


Now let me share two examples of students who practiced in their basements—with very different results.

One student had a real upright piano, but it was located in a far corner of her basement. She often told me she was afraid to make her way to the piano because the basement was cluttered and rather scary.

Another student had a digital piano in his basement. Every morning at 5:00 AM, he went downstairs with a cup of coffee and practiced before driving to work.

Today, five years after his retirement, he still goes downstairs to practice.

For him, that basement is his sacred space.

Same general location. Two entirely different experiences.

My Own Experience with WHERE

One reason I decided to write this blog is that I recently had a surprising experience with where I practice.

But first, let me take you back to the years before the pandemic.

At that time, I had three acoustic pianos and one digital piano available to me, all in different locations.

My gorgeous Yamaha C3 grand piano was in the sanctuary of the church where I served as music director. My Yamaha P2 Studio Upright was in my Natick piano studio, and my Yamaha digital piano was in my home studio.

My fourth piano was a Yamaha P22 Studio Upright in my Hudson piano studio.


On Saturdays, I rehearsed the music I would be playing in church the following day. Afterward, I spent a glorious 90 minutes practicing jazz piano.

The quiet and peacefulness of my Hudson studio created an atmosphere that was absolutely inspiring. It reminded me why I loved playing the piano.

Despite having three other wonderful instruments available, it was in my Hudson studio that I experienced a WHERE that made an enormous difference.

I hadn't given that experience much thought until recently.

Finding the Magic Again

In my Connecticut studio, I had my beautiful 46-year-old Yamaha P2 Studio Upright—the same piano I had used to teach students in my Natick studio for more than twenty years.

A couple of years ago, I was performing every month at our community's Musicale.

To prepare, I practiced the two songs I planned to perform every single day for a month.

But between the piano's location in my studio and the daily routine, something was missing.

The WHERE didn't inspire me.

It felt nothing like practicing in my Hudson studio years earlier.

Several months ago, we decided to move my piano into the living room.

The wood floors gave the instrument a wonderfully resonant sound, and I began practicing quite a bit, hoping to recapture that feeling I'd experienced back in 2016. And then something unexpected happened.

Occasionally, there was activity in the living room, and I couldn't practice on the upright piano.

So one day, I sat down at the digital piano in my studio—the same instrument I use for teaching online. Much to my surprise, the magic happened! I couldn't believe it.

The feeling I suddenly experienced was the same one I'd had while practicing in my Hudson studio.

And here I was, sitting at the digital piano that had been available to me all along!

What Matters Most?

T. S. Eliot once wrote:

“We shall not cease from exploration, and the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we started and know the place for the first time.”

That is exactly what happened to me.

After years of playing different pianos in different locations, I rediscovered something special in a place that had been right in front of me.


And so, I recommend that you pay attention not only to HOW you practice and WHEN you practice, but also to WHERE you practice.

Sometimes a change in your surroundings—or even a fresh experience of a familiar place—can make all the difference in how you feel about sitting down to play.


Diana Mascari's book filled with ideas to inspire you to return to playin the piano

Interested in returning to playing the piano or exploring composition?

If you played the piano in the past and want help reawakening your musical interest, I'd like to help you do that.


If you are an adult student with some musical background and have ever been curious about composing, I would love to help you begin.


🎹 Piano Lessons https://www.mascaripiano.com/piano-lessons  Personalized piano instruction for adults and students of all levels, grounded in musical understanding, technique, and expressive playing.


One-on-one guidance for composers at any stage—whether you’re just beginning, returning after time away, or developing your own musical voice.



Free Consultation  https://www.mascaripiano.com/contact Not sure where to start? Schedule a free consultation to talk about your goals, questions, and the best path forward for you.


Explore complimentary courses designed to spark creativity, build confidence, and help you reconnect with your musical curiosity.


Diana Mascari's book designed to help you learn to use your creative and musical talents to composer your own music.

About Diana Mascari

Composer, Author, Jazz Pianist 

and Teacher of Piano and Composition


Diana Mascari is a composer, pianist, educator, and author whose work bridges classical, jazz, and contemporary music, with a deep commitment to creativity as personal expression. With decades of experience as a performer and teacher, she is passionate about helping musicians reconnect with curiosity, confidence, and their own creative voice.


She is the author of two books on music and creativity, including

Awakening the Composer Within You, which is published and available on Amazon https://a.co/d/07wjywBB 

and

Reawakening the Music Within You, which is published and available on Amazon https://a.co/d/5SW5HhN


For information about piano and composition lessons, free consultations, free courses, and additional resources, visit her website at www.mascaripiano.com.



Comments


bottom of page